JAS Aquatics Pools Pavers and Design

Should You Close Your Pool for Winter? What Long Island Homeowners Actually Need to Do

Not sure whether to close your pool or leave it running this winter? Here's an honest breakdown of what makes sense for Long Island and Queens homeowners.

Share:

Pool technician in a blue uniform kneeling poolside servicing equipment

Summary:

Every fall, Long Island and Queens pool owners face the same question: close it down or keep it running? The answer depends on your pool type, your equipment, and what a Long Island winter actually does to an unprotected system. This post breaks down the real differences between closing and winterizing, covers the rules for above-ground, salt water, and heated pools, and explains why the timing of your closing matters just as much as the process itself. Read this before the temperature drops.
Table of contents

Every fall, the same question comes up in our service calls. Do you have to close your pool, or can you just leave it running with the heater on? And if you do close it, is throwing a cover over it enough?

These are fair questions, and the answers matter more than most people realize. Long Island and Queens winters are unforgiving. The freeze-thaw cycles alone—not just one sustained cold snap, but repeated freezing and thawing throughout the season—put real stress on plumbing, equipment, and liners. Here’s what you actually need to know before you make that call.

Closing a Pool vs. Winterizing a Pool: They're Not the Same Thing

This is the part most homeowners don’t know, and it’s the most important place to start. Closing a pool simply means you’ve stopped using it and covered it up. Winterizing a pool is the full protective process—chemistry balancing, plumbing blowout, equipment draining, and proper cover installation—that actually keeps your pool intact through a cold Long Island winter.

In a warm climate, closing might be enough. On Long Island and in Queens, it isn’t. If you cover a pool without completing the winterization steps, you’re essentially hoping nothing freezes. Sometimes that works. Often, it doesn’t—and the damage shows up in spring when you’re already trying to open.

What Happens If You Skip Proper Pool Winterization?

Water expands roughly 9 to 10 percent when it freezes. That doesn’t sound like much until you picture it happening inside a plumbing line, a pump housing, or a filter tank. The expansion has nowhere to go, so it cracks whatever’s containing it. Pipes split. Pump casings fracture. Filter tanks shatter. And none of that is covered by most homeowners insurance policies when the cause is improper winterization.

The repair costs aren’t trivial. Depending on what breaks and how much, freeze damage can run anywhere from a few hundred dollars to well into the thousands. A professional pool closing done right costs a fraction of that—and it’s a one-time expense each season, not a repair bill that shows up every few years.

There’s also the spring side of this. Algae doesn’t fully stop growing until water temperature drops to around 40°F. If you close your pool while the water is still warm, your winterizing chemicals burn off before winter is even over. By the time you pull the cover in May, you’re looking at a green swamp instead of a clear pool. Getting that back to swim-ready condition takes time, extra chemicals, and often a service call—all of which eats into the short Long Island pool season. With roughly 14 to 16 weeks between Memorial Day and Labor Day, losing even a week or two to spring cleanup is a real cost.

The plumbing blowout is the step that separates a real winterization from a cover-and-hope situation. Clearing every line requires professional-grade compressed air. A home compressor or shop vac doesn’t generate enough pressure to do it completely. Even a small amount of water left in a line is enough to cause a freeze crack. This is the single most common point of failure in DIY pool closings, and it’s the reason most pool owners eventually stop doing it themselves.

When Is the Right Time to Close a Pool on Long Island?

Timing your pool closing correctly is just as important as doing it right. Close too early, and your winterizing chemicals burn off before the water gets cold enough to slow algae growth. Close too late, and you risk a freeze event before the job is done.

For Long Island and Queens, the optimal window is mid-to-late October. That’s when nighttime temperatures consistently drop below 50°F, which is the threshold where algae growth slows significantly and where winterizing chemistry holds through the season. Closing in September might feel proactive, but if the water is still in the mid-60s, you’re actually setting yourself up for a green pool by spring.

Long Island’s climate adds a specific complication that generic winterization guides don’t account for: the freeze-thaw cycle. Unlike climates that go cold and stay cold, Long Island winters move in and out of freezing temperatures repeatedly. A pool that survived one freeze might be stressed by the fifth. Each cycle is a pressure event for plumbing and equipment, which is why proper winterization—not just a cover—is the baseline requirement here, not an optional upgrade.

There’s also a consideration specific to certain parts of Long Island that rarely gets mentioned: the water table. In South Shore communities and other low-lying areas, the seasonal water table can rise significantly in winter. Draining a pool too aggressively in these areas creates a risk of hydrostatic uplift—where groundwater pressure pushes up against the pool shell from below, potentially causing structural damage. A professional who knows the local conditions will account for this. A generic guide won’t mention it at all.

Above-Ground, Salt Water, and Heated Pools: Different Winter Rules for Long Island Homeowners

Most winterization content treats every pool the same. But if you have an above-ground pool, a salt water system, or a pool heater, the standard advice doesn’t fully apply to you. Each of these setups has its own requirements—and getting them wrong can cause the exact damage you were trying to prevent.

Understanding what’s different about your specific pool type isn’t about complicating the process. It’s about making sure the steps you take actually protect what you have.

Above-Ground Pool Winterization: Why You Should Never Fully Drain It

This is one of the most common and costly mistakes above-ground pool owners make: draining the pool completely before winter. It seems logical—remove the water so it can’t freeze. But above-ground pool structures depend on the weight of the water to maintain their shape. Drain it fully, and the walls can collapse inward or the liner can shrink and crack beyond repair.

The correct approach is to lower the water level slightly—typically a few inches below the return jets—not drain it entirely. From there, an air pillow goes under the cover before it’s secured. The pillow sits in the center of the pool and absorbs the pressure of ice forming around it, directing that force away from the pool walls. Without it, ice expansion pushes outward against the walls and can cause serious structural damage over a Long Island winter.

Salt water above-ground pools have an additional step: the salt chlorinator cell needs to come out before freezing temperatures arrive. Salt cells are not freeze-resistant. If water freezes inside the cell, it cracks—and replacement cells aren’t cheap. The cell should be cleaned, stored indoors, and replaced with a dummy cell or plug to keep the plumbing sealed for winter. The SWG also stops producing chlorine once water temperature drops below roughly 50 to 55°F, so if you leave the cell in and assume it’s protecting the water, it isn’t. Your pool chemistry is on its own once the water gets cold.

For inground salt water pools, the same logic applies to the salt cell. Beyond that, the rest of the closing process mirrors a standard inground closing: chemistry balance, full plumbing blowout, equipment draining, and proper cover installation. Salt water pools can withstand slightly colder temperatures than traditionally chlorinated pools before freezing—around 28°F versus 32°F—but that margin isn’t a reason to skip any steps.

Can You Leave a Pool Open All Winter With a Heater Running?

Technically, yes. Practically, it’s rarely the right call for Long Island or Queens homeowners—and it’s worth understanding why before you commit to it.

Keeping a pool open through winter requires a pool heater that’s properly sized for winter temperatures, not just for extending the swim season by a few weeks. It requires freeze protection sensors on the equipment, insulated plumbing, and continuous monitoring. Most residential pool setups aren’t built with this in mind from the start, which means retrofitting for winter operation is often a significant undertaking.

The bigger risk is what happens if something goes wrong. A heater malfunction or a power outage during a cold snap—even one that lasts overnight—can expose an unprotected pool to freezing temperatures with no warning. By the time you realize the heater is down, the damage is already done. Burst pipes, cracked equipment, and a pool full of problems waiting to be discovered in the morning.

There’s also the pool heater winterization question for homeowners who do choose to close. When temperatures drop below 32°F, water left inside a heater expands and cracks internal components—repairs that often run into the thousands. But there’s a second issue that surprises most people: rodents. When plumbing unions are disconnected during a pool closing, the openings in a heater become entry points. Rodents nest inside heaters over winter and cause damage that isn’t discovered until spring startup. Professional winterization includes rodent deterrence treatment on the heater—a step that almost never makes it into a DIY guide.

For most Long Island and Queens homeowners, the cost, complexity, and risk of leaving a pool open through winter outweigh the benefit. A properly winterized pool, closed at the right time and reopened in spring, is a far more predictable outcome.

Pool Winterization Services for Long Island and Queens Homeowners

The difference between a pool that opens clean in May and one that greets you with green water and a repair bill comes down to what happens in October. Not just whether you covered it, but whether you actually winterized it—the right way, at the right time, with the right process for your specific pool type.

We’ve been closing pools on Long Island and in Queens since 2009. We know what these winters do to pools, we know the local conditions that generic guides skip over, and we know how to close a pool so that opening it in spring is straightforward instead of stressful.

If you’re not sure whether your pool is being closed correctly—or you want to stop guessing and hand it off to someone who does this every season—reach out to JAS Aquatics. We’re licensed in both Nassau County and Suffolk County, and we serve homeowners across Long Island and Queens.

Questions about your pool?

Tell us what you need and a JAS Aquatics pool pro on Long Island will get back to you. Prefer to talk now? Call 631-239-8031.

By checking this box, you consent to receive SMS messages from JAS Aquatics, including appointment reminders, service updates, and promotional offers. Message frequency may vary. Message and data rates may apply. Reply STOP to opt out at any time. Reply HELP for assistance. Consent is not a condition of purchase. View our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.

Article details:

Share: