Summary:
Here’s something we hear every fall: “It’s just an above-ground pool — how complicated can it be?” Complicated enough that we spend a significant portion of every spring fixing damage that a proper October closing would have prevented entirely. Above-ground pools get written off as the simple option, and that assumption is exactly what gets homeowners into trouble. Long Island winters are not forgiving, and the mistakes that happen during closing season don’t announce themselves until the weather warms back up. Here are the five most common ones we see — and what you should be doing instead.
Why Above-Ground Pool Closing Is More Complicated Than Most People Think
There’s a common belief that above-ground pools are simpler to close than inground pools because the plumbing is more accessible and the system is less complex. That’s partially true — but it misses something important. Above-ground pool plumbing and equipment run at or above ground level, which means they’re directly exposed to freezing air temperatures. Inground pool pipes run below the frost line, which gives them a layer of natural insulation. Your above-ground pool has no such buffer.
Water expands when it freezes. That expansion is enough to crack PVC pipes, split pump housings, and destroy equipment — and on Long Island, where temperatures regularly drop into the low twenties and freeze-thaw cycles repeat throughout the winter, the risk is real every single season. The five mistakes below are the ones that lead to those outcomes most often.
Mistake #1: Draining the Pool Completely Before Winter
This is probably the most widespread misconception we encounter. The thinking makes intuitive sense — no water, no freeze damage. But completely draining a vinyl-lined above-ground pool before winter is one of the most damaging things you can do to it.
The water inside your pool isn’t just sitting there doing nothing. It holds the liner against the walls and floor, preventing it from drying out, shrinking, and cracking. It also adds structural weight that helps the walls and frame resist wind pressure. Long Island sees significant coastal winds, particularly in communities near the South Shore and along the bays, and an empty above-ground pool is far more vulnerable to frame warping and wall damage than one with water in it.
The correct approach is to lower the water level only a few inches below the skimmer mouth — enough to protect the skimmer from freeze damage, but not so much that the cover sags into the pool or the liner loses its support. The exact amount depends on your cover type, but “drain it completely” is never the right answer for a vinyl-lined above-ground pool.
Liner replacement runs $500 to $800 and should last seven to ten years under normal conditions. Improper winterization accelerates that cycle significantly. It’s an expensive lesson to learn when the fix was simply leaving the water in.
Mistake #2: Skipping the Air Pillow — or Inflating It Wrong
If you’ve closed an above-ground pool before, you may have seen the inflatable pillow that goes in the center of the pool before the cover goes on. A lot of homeowners skip it, either because they don’t know what it does or because it seems like an optional add-on. It isn’t.
When water freezes in an above-ground pool, it expands outward. Without anything to absorb that expansion, the ice pushes against the pool walls, stresses the frame, and can warp or crack the top rail. The air pillow sits in the middle of the pool and gives the ice somewhere to compress into rather than pushing outward against the structure. It also helps shed debris and water accumulation from the cover surface, which matters more than most people realize.
Here’s the part that often gets missed even by people who do use a pillow: it should only be inflated to about 60 to 70 percent capacity. A fully inflated pillow has no give. When ice forms and presses against it, a rigid pillow can actually crack or pop — which defeats the purpose entirely. Partially inflated, it compresses under pressure and does its job.
Water accumulation on the cover is a related issue worth mentioning. When water pools on top of a winter cover and freezes, the weight and tension it creates can pull inward on the top ledges, the skimmer, and the return fittings. This is a slow, invisible form of structural stress that adds up over a Long Island winter. A properly installed cover with secure anchoring, combined with a correctly placed air pillow, goes a long way toward preventing it.
Above-Ground Pool Winterization Mistakes That Damage Your Equipment
Structural damage gets most of the attention, but equipment damage is where the real money gets spent. A cracked pipe is frustrating. A destroyed heat exchanger or a split pump housing is a different conversation entirely. The next two mistakes on this list are the ones most likely to turn a routine closing into an expensive spring repair.
Both of them come down to the same root cause: assuming that “close enough” is good enough when it comes to clearing water out of your system. It isn’t. On Long Island, where temperatures can drop below 28 degrees Fahrenheit and stay there for days at a time, even a small amount of standing water in the wrong place is enough to cause a crack.
Mistake #3: An Incomplete Line Blowout
Blowing out the plumbing lines is the most technically demanding part of closing an above-ground pool, and it’s also the step where DIY closings most frequently fall short. The goal is to remove every bit of standing water from the pipes before temperatures drop — because even one section of pipe with residual water is enough to crack when it freezes.
The problem with doing this yourself is equipment. Consumer shop vacs and small air compressors often can’t generate the pressure and volume needed to fully clear the lines. You might push most of the water out and have no way of knowing whether you’ve gotten all of it. The line looks clear. The pool looks fine. And then February happens.
Professional line blowout uses commercial-grade compressors that deliver enough pressure to clear the entire plumbing system reliably. It’s not a matter of effort or technique — it’s a matter of having the right tool for the job. This is one of the clearest cases where the cost of hiring a professional (above-ground pool closing on Long Island typically runs in the range of $150 to $300) is simply not comparable to the cost of getting it wrong. A single cracked return line costs $400 to $1,200 to repair, and that’s before accounting for any equipment damage.
We’ve been doing this across Long Island and Queens County since 2009, and the pattern is consistent: the closings that lead to spring repair calls are almost always the ones where the line blowout was rushed, done with inadequate equipment, or skipped entirely.
Mistake #4: Ignoring the Heater — and What Saltwater Pool Owners Miss at Closing
The pool heater is the most expensive component in your system to replace if freeze damage occurs. A cracked heat exchanger doesn’t give you much warning — it just fails, and the repair is not cheap. Proper heater winterization means draining the unit completely, shutting it down correctly, and — something most homeowners never think about — treating it for rodents. Mice and other small animals nest in heater units over winter and chew through wiring and insulation. It’s a common source of expensive spring damage that has nothing to do with water or freezing, and it’s entirely preventable.
For saltwater pool owners, there’s an additional layer of complexity that standard closing guides almost never address. The biggest misconception we hear from saltwater above-ground pool owners is that the salt in their water offers some protection against freezing. It doesn’t. Residential pools operate at salt concentrations of roughly 2,700 to 3,400 parts per million — nowhere near enough to meaningfully lower the freezing point. Your saltwater pool will freeze just as readily as any other pool, and it needs the same full winterization protocol.
What saltwater pools need beyond the standard process: the salt cell must be removed before closing, cleaned of mineral scale buildup, and stored indoors for the winter. Leaving the cell in place exposes it to freeze damage and accelerates scaling. You’ll also want a cover rated specifically for saltwater exposure, since standard covers can degrade faster in a saltwater environment. These aren’t optional steps — they’re the difference between a salt cell that lasts and one that needs replacing come spring.
Closing your pool while the water is still above 65 degrees Fahrenheit creates ideal conditions for algae to grow under the cover all winter long. You won’t see it happening. But when you pull the cover in April, you’ll know immediately.
The ideal closing window on Long Island runs roughly from mid-September through mid-October — after the water has cooled but well before the first hard freeze. Getting the timing right matters as much as getting the process right. Close too early and you’re feeding algae. Close too late and you risk a sudden cold snap catching your system unprepared.
Questions about your pool?
Tell us what you need and a JAS Aquatics pool pro on Long Island will get back to you. Prefer to talk now? Call 631-239-8031.

